People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is amazing. Great customer service and the food will keep you coming back. I got the turkey breast bbq baked potato and I was not disappointed. The portion size is massive especially compared to next closest bbq restaurant and it tastes much better as well. This was enough for two of us. Usually I don't share but I always have left overs. Get there early cause they do run out of selections at times ”
“ First off: the peanut butter chess cake is amazing. It could only have been better if I had also bought the chocolate cake and ate them together. The baked potato is vegetarian friendly as it can be ordered without meat (plain with no bacon). It's served with a generous helping of sour cream, cheese, butter and chives and is totally delicious. I assumed but didn't ask if there was ham or bacon in the beans and greens. My husband got the pulled pork sandwiches, potato salad and yams and loved it all. Definitely will be going back to try the other food options! ”
“ I found out about this place through a coworker. Omg I really like it you get your money's worth. I ordered Chopped Beef Potato and my husband the 4 meat Jaitlin5k Potato and 2 mini pies and a can of Big Red total out to 40.86. Wow this food will hold me 4 two days I like that. Pictures will tell it all. I will be going back! ”
“ I'm george & cynthias original smoke this guy have some great BBQ IM A PIT MASTER BUT I RECOMMEND IF YOUR IN LANCASTER TEXAS. ”
“ Delicious BBQ baked potato. The Chopped beef was tender and the BBQ sauce is good. Can't wait to try other options. ”
“ Really good atmosphere small place though. Great food even better customer service. ”
“ The baked potato was delicious. I will definitely be back for more. ”
“ Im really hard on barbecue places, but I must say that the barbecue here is absolutely good. The prices are reasonable and they have a really big menu. The loaded backed potato is very tender, and the barbecue sauce is something that I would call amazing. Everything on their menu is delicious. I will be returning soon. Definitely a must try you will not be disappointed ”
About
GatorPit BarBQ
Welcome to GatorPit BarBQ, a hidden gem located at 2555 N Dallas Ave, Lancaster, TX 75134. If you’re a fan of mouth-watering barbecue, this spot is a must-visit. With a reputation for delivering hearty portions and flavorful dishes, GatorPit BarBQ has quickly gained a loyal following among locals and visitors alike.
Customer experience here is paramount, reflected in their amazing service as highlighted by guests like Torrey Hammond, who noted, “The food will keep you coming back.” The famed turkey breast BBQ baked potato is a standout dish, often described as generously portioned and filled with rich flavors. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that’s meant to be shared — Torrey mentions having enough leftovers for two, showing just how satisfying these servings can be.
For those with a sweet tooth, the dessert options shouldn’t be overlooked. Erin Daniel praised the peanut butter chess cake, which, she suggests, pairs perfectly with chocolate cake for the ultimate indulgence. This reflects the care and creativity that the team at GatorPit BarBQ puts into their menu, ensuring there’s something delectable for everyone.
Options extend beyond barbecue, too. The baked potatoes, as noted by Erin, can be customized for vegetarians, featuring a robust helping of toppings that elevate the experience. From the pulled pork sandwiches to sides like potato salad and yams, there’s an extensive selection waiting to intrigue your taste buds.
Customers like Tammie Mims have highlighted the incredible value for money, with dishes so hearty they often stretch across multiple meals. Her Chopped Beef Potato, combined with a 4-meat Jaitlin5k Potato, illustrates the portion sizes that dominate GatorPit’s offerings, ensuring every dollar spent feels worthwhile.
Even experienced BBQ enthusiasts, such as George Davis, vouch for the quality, emphasizing that GatorPit BarBQ is a must-try when in Lancaster. The dedication to perfecting smoky flavors and tender cuts shows through every plate served.
Whether you’re tackling a delicious BBQ baked potato or diving into a selection of meaty dishes, GatorPit BarBQ embodies everything a great BBQ joint should be: tasty, festive, and thoroughly satisfying. Ready to taste what all the hype is about? Pick up the phone and call +1 214-680-5431 for takeout, or stop by and join the community of barbecue lovers today!
Book a table